The Sonia Show

Writer. Mocker. Beer drinker. Old movie watcher. Mother. Goober.

The Dork Side: The Voice > American Idol


Yeah, so, my name is Sonia Mansfield, and I used to be an “American Idol” fan.

There. I said it.

I was totally into it. I watched everything from the awkward auditions to the drawn-out finale. I watched it five months out of the year, sometimes watching all six hours a week that it was airing. I used to blog about it weekly with recaps and predictions.

"Hi. I have a nice personality, and I can kinda-maybe sing, and I won American Idol."

But during the last few seasons, my interest started to wane. I got tired of attractive, mediocre singers making it to the final rounds. It became clear to me that the producers, the judges and the “Idol” voters had ceased being interested in finding the best singer. They even put a comedian on the judging panel, because hey, who better to judge singers and offer advice than a comedian, right? Then they ditched the comedian, Simon Cowell left, and they added a washed-up rock star, a high maintenance singer/actress/fashionista and well, whatever Randy Jackson is. Everyone seemed more interested in finding someone who was cute with a nice personality and/or sob story that could kinda-maybe sing.

That’s when I decided I was out. I was quitting “American Idol.” I thought it would be difficult, but it wasn’t. I didn’t need any special gum or patch. I just stopped watching and spent my time catching up on shows such as “Breaking Bad.” I think I made the smart choice.

When I heard about NBC’s new singing competition show, “The Voice,” I was hesitant to watch it. I didn’t want to relapse and get sucked into another crappy singing competition show. But the premise of “The Voice” intrigued me: Blind auditions. The judges can’t see the contestants. They just hear them sing. They don’t get to see if they are hot. They don’t get to hear their sob story. It was all about the singing.

So I watched it … and I was hooked.

And I wasn’t the only one. My husband, who left the room whenever I watched “American Idol” in the past, started watching it, too. There are a lot of things I like about “The Voice,” but my main attraction to it is that this show appears to want to actually find a good singer. Imagine that.

Which brings me to this week’s Dork Side: 5 reasons “The Voice” is better than “American Idol.” Honesty, I could have probably come up with more than five reasons, but then I would be really outing myself as a huge TV nerd.


Author: The Sonia Show

I'm a writer/podcaster/mother/goober in San Francisco who likes to drink beer, shop, laugh and make other people laugh, watch old movies, feed my unhealthy obsession with pop culture, kick breast cancer's ass, go on adventures with my mighty, mighty good man David and my awesome autistic son, Calvin, wear orange and root for the San Francisco Giants, participate in general jackass-ery, talk about TV, eavesdrop on strangers' conversations, make nerdy “Star Wars” and “Simpsons” references, and post personal things about myself on the web for all to read, which makes me some sort of literary exhibitionist.

2 thoughts on “The Dork Side: The Voice > American Idol

  1. I am sad to say that I still watch American Idol. I keep holding on for hope that at some point they’re going to realize that they could still produce another Kelly or Carrie. But they need to do a hell of a better job picking the finalists.

    We’ll see if my viewing of the show survives grad school.

  2. Pingback: Why I’m not watching ‘The Voice’ this season | The Sonia Show

Leave a comment, you guys. It's fun!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s